User:Econterms/Lightning talk

From WikiConference North America
< User:Econterms
Revision as of 14:08, 1 June 2014 by Econterms (talk | contribs) (emphasis)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Tracking relations between scientific works, such as disputes

  • Prof. Yang tells Lane and me that students have trouble interpreting a dynamic immunology literature which includes published papers whose findings are wrong or irrelevant.
  • We are imagining a wiki platform that made the state of research in a science more clear.
  • Here's a feature it could have.

Examples:

  • AcaWiki has 1100 academic summaries.
  • See first two examples
  • Substantive comment is formalized: A disputes B (using Semantic MediaWiki)
  • Similarly could incorporate other relations between scientific works: A cites B ; A is an important predecessor to B ; A and B use the same data set or the same clinical trial information
  • note that the platform doesn't generally resolve claims or disputes ; it's finding a shallower kind of Truth
  • Could scale this up with big lists of relevant papers and works from many places including PubMed, SSRN, and Wikidata
The list is not an innovation but the relations between the works can be useful if they are formalized a bit
  • Trees of relationships can then be made visible ; could give a picture of a literature
  • Useful for:
  1. students of this research or
  2. researchers not at a "central" place that is well-connected to the latest news (global South?)
  3. somebody with some other expertise (or technology or skill) that helps to address the specific question of fact.
Opportunities are rare if subfield has knowledge & institiutional barriers around it.
===> A good site could save time for scientists and bring in more scientists ===> speed science along

We need more people and ideas of what a wiki with scientific lit should have

Sources:

  • developed with Lane Rasberry (WM NYC), Otto Yang (UCLA medicine), others
  • drawing from Yaron Koren's discoursedb.org ; Retraction Watch blog; other sites